Sunday, January 22, 2012

Literacy Timeline and Textual Lineage Reflection

Writing my own literacy timeline was eye opening in many ways. I had never before reflected on my literacy history. One aspect of my timeline that really stood out to me was that I learned to read music and write my name before I could read text. After noticing this I started to think about the kids in my life and their literacy. I realized that all of them are learning to write the alphabet and spell their names before they're being asked to to read sentences. This is really strange to me. It seems like we should teach kids to read before they write. This observation leaves me wanting to do some research into why we learn to write first because it seems like putting the cart before the horse to me.

The first book I have on my timeline is a children's book called Rabbit Hill. I haven't thought about this book in years, but I have very fond memories of my mother reading it to me. I ordered the book off of Amazon.com, and started re-reading it the other day. It wasn't until now that I realized the book is full of social commentary. I wonder how many other texts of my youth have social agendas behind them. I'm suddenly very skeptical of the Golden Books. ( I still and always will love Rabbit Hill).

I love the idea of teaching literacy timeline in my class. While literacy territories are a great way for some to get to know themselves as readers, it did not help me much. After attempting to create my territories I realized I simply had a couple of pages of seemingly random things I like to read occasionally sorted into categories. I now know my problem was a lack of focus. The timeline forced me to focus my attention to my literacy in a chronological way. After creating the timeline, I went back and tried to create territories again and was much more successful in creating something meaningful to me. When I teach literacy identity in my class, I will first have students create a timeline and then territories.

5 comments:

  1. I think the same about the social agendas in childhood books. I was just talking about this to someone today! And how knowing what I know now, I want to be very thoughtful about the books I decide to read to my children. It is also really awesome to me to think about how you could read music before text. It is pretty fascinating and a really good indicator of what it is that you love to do!
    As far as the reading territories, it showed me a pattern of my reading. What I liked to read and then the empty categories show maybe where I can go back and explore more or decide if I like those at all. Hopefully, they will be helpful in trying to help our students find their niche in reading.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I had a similar intuitive response to your observation about the reading/ writing schema that seems to dominate our school system. If you can read it naturally follows you at least understand the idea of writing--even if you cannot write well or even form letters on the page.
    Perhaps traditional practitioners felt that because children make marks and draw before they can write/ read then they should be taught to write first. I had trouble with this concept when I was a child in school because my parents taught me to read first and write second.
    I wonder if teaching children to read first would be more beneficial. How would this effect their reading skills? Their benchmarks? Their abilities to think critically and engage with varieties of text? If they could read first would they become more successful readers?

    ReplyDelete
  3. The ability to look in and understand our abilities to read in chronological order has given all of us a new understanding of who we are as both readers and writers. Writing before reading is putting the cart before the horse? Maybe, but I've always felt more of a natural inclination toward writing. It wasn't until I reached college that I really understood the necessity of both. If you don't read you can't write. You don't have the words or knowledge to bring into your writing if you're not well-read. This is definitely true, but before we can recognize words or phrases we need to be able to have a physical understanding of what they look like. I think it's almost like looking at an apple, or the word apple. We have to write it to know what it is. I'm not sure what kind of sense that makes, but this is probably a debated topic in the field of education. Why else would we put the cart before the horse?

    ReplyDelete
  4. As always, you bring some interesting points to the table. It's been very beneficial to our cohort to have someone with a theater and music background; it helps us to experience literature from more angles than just the traditional sit-and-read method.

    This was also the first time I've ever really sat down to think about my own literacy history. I had never considered the things that have impacted my life as a reader - both good and bad. And I was pretty surprised by what I remembered. I couldn't find as many negative experiences as I probably actually have, if I were to think more in-depth about my reading life as a whole.

    You bring up an especially interesting point when you talk about how we should be learning to read before we learn how to write. I might argue that most of the people in our cohort did experience reading before learning to write - through our parents reading to us aloud before bed or something similar. (Sadly, not everyone has the same experience). I have never thought about when I learned to write vs. when I learned to read. For me, I think it happened gradually together - I remember starting out with phonics and learning what the individual characters/letters/combinations made (a beginning of the reading process) and learning how to write these letters/characters/combinations. So, in a way, I did learn them simultaneously.

    I also love your comment about your reading territories being all over the place! I'm glad I'm not the only one who feels that way! I look at my reading territories, and the only thing I can determine is that my territories are broad and thin at the same time (meaning that I have a long list of genres and categories, etc. but very few things listed under these headings). I guess it's because I didn't really label myself as a "reader" until college, where I chose to become an English major and, consequently, a reader. Under my degree, I had many different classes that I had to take, and each class approached literature differently. Which is great, until I try to pinpoint exactly what literature speaks to me the most and has had a substantial impact on my life.

    ReplyDelete
  5. That is such an interesting/good point about why students are taught to write some things before they even know how to read. That would be such interesting research to know the reasoning, if any, behind that method.

    I never read Rabbit Hill, but I understand it being strange when you re-read a book you read as a child and finding underlying messages that you never caught as a child. It makes you wonder about all that you read...even children's movies!!

    I liked the literacy timeline as well -- more than reading territories (although I won't completely rule those out). It would be an interesting thing to do in a reading workshop.

    ReplyDelete